I do this every book I try to write, and nearly every story I conceive of. There are historical time periods that capture my imagination, that spread out before me full of panoply and grandeur – and stories. But I face an impasse: do I use history or do I make it up?
There are virtues to both paths, of course. I can either weave magic into existing British history (a la Judith Tarr), or I can make something up that looks kind of British (a la nearly every epic fantasy novel of a certain type.) I can tie myself to something closely resembling historical events in Venice (think Dangerous Beauty), or I can fashion something that looks like Spain, evolves like Spain, but isn’t Spain (Guy Gavriel Kay, for instance).
I can use the richness of Ancient Egypt and tie myself to the historical facts as recorded, or I can craft something that suits the story better. The advantages to using Egypt-as-it-may-have-been? It’s all there for me. I have the names of the gods, the myths, the rituals, the language. If I make something that suits me better, I get to play with that history, make it something else. I can make Khenepres and Hatsepsut contemporaries. I can have a slave race that may or may not be monotheistic escaping from a brutal tyranny. I can have a princess of another people hiding with the ruling class while a war is fought in her name across the sea. And I can have it all happen at the same time if I want.
But then I have to start from scratch. I need a language, a culture, names. And how much snipping, revising, and phutzing is appropriate? While I don’t think I’d have a line of Egyptian lesbians pounding on my door to tell me how I’ve done it all wrong and treated their culture with disrespect, what if I did the same with something more modern? What if, say, I wanted to create a story about a colonized country breaking free – but still keeping their slaves? Would this revision of early American history – not called that, of course – offend? Or is it all just fiction?
Regardless, I need to make some sort of decision on this, or I will continue to research times and places that fascinate me, make up stories in my head, and then … let them go. Nothing on paper, because I don’t know if it’s tied to history or not. And the bitch of it is, I can’t seem to make up my mind. Last week, I was all set to use Egyptian history as it is now known, and this week, I think I should just mirror it into a different world, so I can make it into the story I really want to tell.
Oh, for Kay’s talent at playing with mythology! If I could just create one world, and make it like our history, only not. Of course, now that I say that, I have Ideas.
Consecutive days of writing: 001Longest previous streak: 007Word count since 4/30/09: 5481