This is the book:
Chainfire, by Terry Goodkind. This is the 9th book in the Sword of Truth saga, and the beginning of the final trilogy.
The book itself was not bad, though it’s part of a series I don’t particularly enjoy. You might ask why I read it then. I am a bit of a compulsive reader when it comes to fantasy series. I have to finish them. No matter how bad they are, I don’t think I’ve ever walked away from a series in the middle. (I lie – I just thought of one. The Voyage of the Jerle Shannara series by Terry Brooks. Not that I don’t like Terry Brooks as a person, I just find his writing dull and subpar.) So I continue reading this series, knowing what awaits me. See, here’s the thing. I like this series
as I’m reading it. In retrospect, not so much.
This review is not going to make a whole lot of sense for you if you haven’t read the previous eight books. Just sayin’. The rant after the review is probably going to be more entertaining, so I won’t be hurt if you just skip down there.
Okay, am I left with just Sword of Truth readers (or voyeurs)? Good.
The beginning of the book shows us the main character, Richard, being frantically rushed to a farmhouse to be healed from a grievous battle wound. When he comes to, he goes out looking for his wife, Kahlan, only to realize that, not only do people not know where she is, they don’t know WHO she is. All memory of Kahlan has been stripped away from everyone’s minds. Events that she played a part in are rationalized in some other manner, and everyone, right down to Richard’s closest confidante, Cara, believes he made Kahlan up in a fever-induced delirium when he was ill. Now, this made me doubt Richard for about three sentences. Then I remembered that Goodkind loves Richard, and Richard would never, ever be an unreliable narrator. Therefore, Richard is right. It just remains to figure out how.
Richard spends several hundred pages running around asking everyone if the know who Kahlan is, to the vast detriment of the war effort. (
Hey, Richard, remember the war? The last hope of mankind? Happening in your
kingdom of D’Hara? Remember them?) He even refuses to head the battle at Altur’Rang when Emperor Jagang comes back to claim his home city from the rebels. That’s okay, though, because Richard is always right, and obviously finding Kahlan is more important than saving the free world.
Meanwhile, Ann and Nathan are discovering prophecies gone missing. Books of prophecy that they both have practically memorized have suddenly developed blank pages, and what’s more, no one can remember what they once said. Sound familiar? Yep, I bet this is tied in with Kahlan. The sections with Nathan and Ann are quickly emerging as my favorite passages. Nathan’s dry wit and cynicism offer a fresh contrast to Richard’s saccharine speeches. (Though the Rahl arrogance gets a little old.)
I can’t reveal much more without ruining the plot, but this is NOT a standalone book. When you get to the end, you’ll only have uncovered the mystery – nothing will be solved. But you will discover what’s up with missing Kahlan, why prophecy pages are missing, and the true purpose behind the boxes of Orden. We’re nicely set up for the next two books, where Richard gets to Save the World. Again.
Don’t get me wrong. I enjoyed the book. I just skipped the oh, innumerable pages of Goodkind-as-Richard’s philosophy. They’re not hard to miss – it’s generally five pages at a time of Richard talking. The thing is, Goodkind writes a pretty decent quest novel. If you’re into quest novels, and you don’t mind dodging the heavy-handed philosophy, it’s not a bad read.
Don’t worry, the wait isn’t likely to be too long, as Amazon already has the next book listed.
Okay, the rant**:
Here’s a taste, just a small one, of what Terry Goodkind says about his books being labeled fantasy:
My books were defined in the marketplace as fantasy purely because of business considerations, not essential characteristics. In the business of selling books, the fact that there are elements of magic in my novels and, far more importantly, that I am published by a fantasy publisher, nullifies every other consideration.Okay. His books are set in a mythical, pseudo-medieval world, where every single one of the main characters has some sort of magic, where the main character is, in fact, a “war wizard,” and the series’ first book is called
Wizard’s First Rule. Which part of this does he not consider fantasy? The dragon in the first book? The magic of the Confessors? The boundaries between countries? The Sisters of Light? The struggle to save the world from the Keeper of the Underworld? What, exactly, Mr. Goodkind do you not see as essential characteristics in that list?
Are you a fantasy fan? I know I am. Terry Goodkind hates us. Hates the fact that his books are labeled fantasy. Why? Because his books, by god, have serious social and philosophical commentary in them. Fantasy fans are obviously tripe-loving denizens of the deep that only come out of the cave when stumbling across a rare gem like HIS books. Obviously, Robert Heinlein, Frank Herbert, Dan Simmons, and John C. Wright are also clearly mislabeled. Their books should not be considered “Science Fiction” just because they are set on distant worlds and use space travel. After all, those aren’t
essential characteristics. Like hell, Mr. Goodkind.
He goes on to say (at great length) that is books are NOVELS, due to the characteristics of Theme, Plot, and Characterization. Well and good. I think his books are novels, too. But does this sound to anyone else that he thinks maybe Fantasy novels (oops, books) aren’t novels? Are they somehow less worthy? Respectfully, Mr. Goodkind, get off your damned high horse. Just because you write fantasy, that does not make you an unrespected artist. (Your prose does, though, and your incessant mewling about how it sucks to be saddled with the fantasy label. And your ill-thought out philosophy based on reading Ayn Rand novels when you were an impressionable youth. I could continue. Really, being labelled a fantasy author is the least of your worries.)
And this, this is what made me rethink my decision to give this author any more of my money.
Question: Lately I've found myself in many arguments defending your books against 'fans' who say they used to like your books but no longer do to the extent that they used to. Would you mind settling some debates by answering the Question: What, if anything do you have to say to the people that voice the opinion that you're latest four books haven't been as good as the previous four and call them "too preachy"?
Answer: Don't be fooled. The assertion made by these detractors is a note wrapped around a brick thrown through the window. These people are not fans. There are hundreds if not thousands of fantasy books that fulfill their professed taste in books. Why would they continue to read books they claim are bad? Because they hate that my novels exists. Values arouse hatred in these people. Their goal is not to enjoy life, but to destroy that which is good -much like a school child who does not wish to study for a test and instead beats up a classmate who does well. These people hate what is good because it is good. Their lives are limited to loathing and indifference. It isn't that they want to read a good book, what they want is to make sure that you do not. Ignore them.I’m just speechless with rage at this point. Values arouse hatred in me? I hate that his books exist? I want to destroy all life? JUST because I think his books are two preachy? Shoot me. Shoot me now. Better yet, shoot him.
Gah. Reading the whole thing over again made me cranky. Go
read it yourself. Really. I’ve only begun to scratch the surface of what infuriates me about it. This rant is already too long as it is, and I don’t want to bore you further. But do read it. It’s at least worth a good laugh. (I’m stopping myself from rereading the rest of it, because I don’t want to start frothing at the mouth with rage while at work. Reputation, you know.) When you're done, go read the
very good rebuttal.
**All quotes above are taken from the Prophet’s Inc live chat, the text of which can be found at http://www.terrygoodkind.com/chats/PIchat5.php.